Twenty-five years ago, Craig Zoberis and his wife, Tracy, had a white chocolate mousse wedding cake from Toni's Patisserie & Café. A couple of weeks before The Hinsdalean ran its story this fall, Toni Cox made a copy of the cake's top tier for the couple's early anniversary. This time Zoberis was more than a customer. He is one of the bakery's three new owners.
That cake explains a lot about what's happening downtown this year. Long-held buildings and businesses around First and Washington are being bought by people who already live in Hinsdale. They're keeping the storefronts familiar and putting their changes into the spaces upstairs and in back.
The bakery sale that came with the recipe box
According to The Hinsdalean, Zoberis and fellow Hinsdale residents Mark Konieczka and Tom Wake bought Toni's earlier this year from Toni Cox and her husband, Paul Pell. The couple had opened the shop at 51 S. Washington St. 32 years ago. Zoberis told the paper he first saw the listing in November through Eatz, a broker that sells restaurants, and knew right away which business it was from the description. Another buyer's deal fell through the first week of January, and the broker called him.
The new owners bring varied backgrounds. Wake worked in wholesale distribution, and Konieczka in commercial real estate. Wake calls Zoberis "a serial entrepreneur and engineer." Konieczka's wife, Stephanie, studied at Le Cordon Bleu in Paris. Wake explained his reason for joining in one line: "I'm failing at my recent retirement. You can only play so many games of Wordle."
The details of the sale matter if you have a standing order there:
- The recipes came with the business. Cox described them as handwritten, typed and in the computer system, "kind of like an old cookbook."
- Cox is staying on through the transition, and Steve Rennau is keeping his role as director of operations.
- The owners have no immediate changes planned. Down the road, they may expand a drink list that has been limited to wine and beer.
That last item has already moved forward. At its October meeting, the Village Board voted 6-0 to approve Class B4 and Class B6 liquor licenses for Toni's, The Hinsdalean's meeting roundup reported. Konieczka's preview: "Perhaps there are bloody Marys in the future."
The first real test comes over the next ten weeks. "The fourth quarter is always a huge thing for us and a lot of work," Cox told the paper. The holiday orders you place this season will be the first ones handled under the new ownership, using the same recipes.
One corner over, a landlord taking the same approach
A week before the Toni's story, The Hinsdalean profiled Pete Tortorello and Fairfield Properties. Tortorello has lived in Hinsdale for 20 years, and many of his investors are local. His firm has bought five downtown buildings since November 2025, and his own office is at 11 E. First. "It's kind of fun - I can walk from building to building," he said.
Here is what's in each building now and what's planned, based on that report:
| Building | At street level today | What's changing |
|---|---|---|
| 11-21 E. First St. | 10 Friends, Sweet William, Blue Mercury | Apartments and offices upstairs; his first purchase, November 2025 |
| 102 S. Washington St. | Alixandra Blue on the garden level, Studio W on the first floor | A two-floor, 2,025-square-foot "Owners Unit" apartment upstairs |
| 8-10 W. First St., the "yellow house" | Under renovation | Planned home of Frame Bridge, an online custom framing company |
| Small building behind 8-10 W. First | Former salon, about 700 square feet | Being upgraded for a tenant not yet named |
| 104-106 S. Washington St. | My Eye Doctor | Second-floor offices becoming four one-bedroom apartments as leases expire |
Most of the shop names in the first column are staying. The changes are in the third column.
Where the changes show up
Upstairs. The 102 S. Washington building went up in 1888, built by tailor John Papenhausen for his business. His family of eight lived on the second floor, and it was the only commercial building on the south side of First Street at the time. That second floor is becoming a three-bedroom, three-bath apartment with a full kitchen and in-unit laundry. It's listed at $7,000 a month, and the turret window looks out over the business district. Tortorello estimates downtown has only 20 to 25 apartments. "They're kind of tucked away and people don't know about them - and most of them are vintage," he said. He sees an audience among people who "want to keep a local presence, even a smaller footprint." Over on Washington, turning offices into apartments means installing sprinklers throughout the building, which he called a significant investment.
Behind the main buildings. The former salon behind the yellow house is getting new siding, a bay window, skylights and an accessible bathroom. Its door is moving east to line up with the walkway from First Street, so the space will be visible from the sidewalk. The parking area in front of it could become a brick paver patio for the right tenant. Tortorello is open about the kind of tenant he'd like:
"It could be a food use. It could be retail. It could be anything. I think we need more food options for quick bites in Hinsdale."
He isn't the only one thinking that way. In June, The Hinsdalean reported that Fuller House owners Sam and Patricia Vlahos won Village Board approval for Humble Patty, a burger and soft-serve spot in the former Dips & Dogs space at 50 S. Garfield Ave. The plan includes outdoor dining, and the occupancy permit depends on a safety barrier between the patio and the parking spaces for Fullers Home & Hardware. The name honors their father, whom customers always called "such a humble guy," and Patty, Sam's sister. Sam had hoped to open by Labor Day.
In the rent. Tortorello is straightforward that upgraded buildings will cost tenants more. "You're making a significant investment in the property and there's a lot of spending power in the community," he told The Hinsdalean. "I have investors and want to deliver a better product, and that costs money." The small building behind the yellow house is listed at $4,000 a month.
Why so many buildings are changing hands at once
Tortorello says many downtown buildings that one family owned for decades have changed hands recently. The timing shows up in county records. In January, The Hinsdalean reported that three downtown buildings changed hands in three months the previous fall, based on DuPage County Recorder of Deeds data:
- 18 W. First St., the former Expressions Gallery of Fine Art, sold for $1.93 million on Sept. 10.
- 11 E. First St., home of 10 Friends, sold for $4.5 million on Nov. 19.
- 108 S. Washington St. sold for $2.2 million on Dec. 4.
The same article noted that the former Hinsdale Flower Shop building at 17 W. First had also sold.
The same report explains why buyers want in. As of the fourth quarter of 2025, the village's retail occupancy rate was 98 percent. Andrianna Peterson, Hinsdale's assistant village manager, told the paper, "We're very fortunate to have a lot of interest and not really enough inventory to match all of the interest with that inventory."
With 98 percent of storefronts full, a new owner has little reason to swap out a tenant that's already working. That's why a bakery sale comes with the recipe box and the founder staying on, and why the new money is going into apartments upstairs and a once-overlooked back building. "I'm trying to create homes for businesses so they can be successful," Tortorello said. Zoberis put the same idea in bakery terms: "Carrying her legacy is the key thing because she is behind all of this success."
Seeing it for yourself between now and December
The fall and holiday calendar will take you past all of these buildings:
- Friday, Oct. 23, 5 to 9 p.m. A Haunting at TCH at The Community House, 415 W. Eighth St. The Hinsdalean's Fallapalooza listing recommends the haunted house for ages 8 and up.
- Saturday, Oct. 24, 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. Hinsdale Family Fall Fest at Hinsdale Middle School and downtown, with downtown trick-or-treating, crafts, a costume contest and a free pumpkin for each of the first 500 participants. The village hosts it with the library, the Chamber, The Community House and The Hinsdalean.
- Wednesday, Oct. 28. Boo Bash from 4 to 5 p.m. and The Haunted Page from 7 to 8 p.m. at the Hinsdale Public Library, 20 E. Maple St., according to The Hinsdalean's earlier listing.
- Friday, Dec. 4, 5 to 7 p.m. The Chamber's 60th annual Christmas Walk, with Santa, a tree lighting, a holiday train and a carousel.
Trick-or-treating downtown on Saturday will take you past the Toni's counter on Washington and the gray siding going up on the yellow house on First. By the Christmas Walk, Toni's will be well into the holiday season Cox called "a huge thing for us."
If you'd like to talk about how changes like these downtown play into life in Hinsdale, from new apartments above the shops to what might fill the space behind the yellow house, Jamie Fudym of Envision Homes Now follows this village closely and is always happy to compare notes. Schedule a free consultation, or browse the Hinsdale neighborhood guide to see more of what makes downtown work.